Friday, February 4

When you give alms...

Our theology professor was telling us in class last week about going to Russia once, and experiencing an Orthodox church service.  Being in seminary, I get to hear idealized recreations of various orthodox church services all the time (usually accompanied with wistful sighs), but in this particular case, he referred to what happened after the service, when the people walked out the doors.  There, lined up along both sides of the walk, were the poor, the disenfranchised, the disabled, old, sick, and helpless people from the community, lined up with their hands out, waiting to receive alms.  Imagine this the next time you walk out of a Sunday service - how would the folks in your church react?  I know in my neighborhood the police patrols would be stepped up and the loitering laws and zoning ordinances would come under immediate fire!

Now add to this shocking picture - my professor said that everyone, from the old lifelong church-goers to the young disaffected teenagers in Guns 'n Roses t-shirts (who obviously didn't come of their own free will), absentmindedly reached into their pockets and began handing out coins and bills.  No shock, no second thoughts - just free money changing hands.  He attributes this in part to the idea that the Enlightenment never really happened in Russia, that they have no idea what it might be like to live in a society where capital and productivity are the prime values.

Here in America, we don't know what to do with people who don't contribute their 'fair share' (measured, of course, in monetary value).  The poor, that is- the old, sick, weak, very young, severely disabled, etc.- are all marginalized by our skewed measure of personal worth, and our society has trouble interacting people who require its aid to survive.  On one side of the spectrum, we say that they should be able to pull themselves up by their own bootstraps - that they must want to be poor or they'd work harder.  On the other, that poverty itself is the problem and we should do all in our power to eliminate it. 

"Blessed are the poor," Jesus said, not "cursed are the poor," not "there shouldn't be any poor."  "Blessed are the poor."  Again and again in the Bible, "the poor" are attributed God's special favor and protection, and in parables and stories, they tend to come out on top.  In his 1890 (ish) theological critique of the ideals of the Enlightenment / Industrial Revolution, the pope gently pointed out that the poor still had some very much worthwhile value to society: they can pray for the rest of us.  I don't know about you, but I wouldn't mind parting with some pocket change once in a while in return for someone with favored status from God interceding on my behalf...

7 comments:

  1. Hi Michael, This is beautiful. I'm going to print it out and take it with me to Alms ministry on Tuesday for all to read. Seeing this, and the other entries on this blog, makes me thankful to have been a part of your discernment process here at St. Paul's. There is a wonderful sermon here!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Very nice, Michael! Now, I was in this same class...how is it I have no recollection of this story?

    ReplyDelete
  3. Mary, I was thinking of the alms ministry when I wrote this - I hope they enjoy this!

    Christine - different theology class ;)

    Thanks for reading.

    ReplyDelete
  4. The alms ministry at St. Paul's is an amazing group and church members give generously to the work that it does. The alms ministry though is a bit different than the scene you described, Michael. This church in Russia has a much more viceral experience of almsgiving than do those who donate to the Alms Ministry. I'm not saying one is better than the other but there is something about seeing the face of the recipient of your alms giving that happens in the story you tell.

    Christ commanded us to feed the poor and clothe the naked, not just pay someone else to do it. I cant help but think about what happened at St. Paul's when those in need came to the Church in large numbers on Sunday to be fed at our Sunday Breakfast. I understand the arguments for shutting down breakfast but am still very uncomfortable with the fact that, when given a similar oppurtunity as this church in Russia has, we turned the poor, disabled and homeless away. I still hope and pray that our community comes up with a creative solution to share of our resources and ourselves more.

    Michael, in light of your studies so far, do you have any thoughts on the dilemma that arose when poor people came to eat breakfast at St. Paul's? Or more generally how wealthy churches in America might reach out more directly to those in need?

    ReplyDelete
  5. Ryan,
    I have lots of thoughts about the dilemmas facing wealthy churches in America today, and I think the issue at its core is one of identity. The church at large, as well as any particular church, must be well aware of its identity and specific calling before it can begin to engage in any particular mission, however noble.

    Others have commented on this in helpful ways and at length: "Christianity for the Rest of Us" by Diana Butler Bass, and "Take This Bread" by Sara Miles both tell wonderful stories of churches that blunder and discern their ways into God's calling.

    Michael

    ReplyDelete
  6. Thanks. Definitely important to be thoughtful and intentional when responding to what Christ calls us too...though following God will be messy at times.

    Talked to Bill and Julia. Sounds like things are going good in Austin. We'll be in Dallas next weekend but I think thats still about a million miles from Austin.

    ReplyDelete